Thank you! Instead, you could post pictures of your state 3rd on the image gallerystarpug wrote:Phenylethylamine wrote:I spent between twenty and forty hours on my prebuild between Regionals and States, adding multiple creative additions and a huge amount of detail; I read all about PARP, and we came out of the test/onsite feeling that we completely nailed both. We were certain we'd medaled, and thought we had a significant chance of the elusive first place.
So we were rather surprised when we didn't medal, and turned out to have gotten ninth.
In retrospect, I'm guessing this was my fatal mistake: I didn't realize that it wasn't going to be the same event supervisor as last year. Last year's supervisor (who some of you may remember as kwijiborjt) wanted detail, detail, detail – chemically accurate, high-level creative additions. So that's how I built my model, with heteroatoms of relevant residues shown in CPK colors, and different colored thread corresponding to different types of bonds between residues, and so on. I tried to make my creative additions creative, with some more complex stuff in addition to the obvious additions, trying to show a deeper understanding of the protein's function. And I think some of it may have gone over the heads of the judges, who were probably judging the event for the first time and adhering exactly to the grading guidelines issued by MSOE. My more advanced creative additions wouldn't have been on the list of likely/suggested creative additions (which event supervisors are encouraged to look beyond at their own discretion), and may not have received any points. Similarly, my explanations for why the highlighted residues in the onsite were important (which came straight from the primary citation for 3OD8.pdb) may have been too technical and might not have gotten as many points as a more general explanation.
It's a shame – I think this is a better event when there's room to push your understanding farther – but at the same time, it's a good reminder that you should never rely too heavily on a particular supervisor's grading/writing style for your strategy in any event.
I can send you my state 3rd if you want. I don't think we could have gotten 3rd without your posts and contributions to the wiki. I can't wait to compete against you at nationals.
But back to fawning, Phenyl, you are seriously one of the best contributors on the site in general 
